An argument on the decision of the united states to drop the atomic bomb on the city of hiroshima
Truman replied that he had purposefully delayed the meeting for as long as possible to give the Manhattan scientists more time. The end of the war was good news to us. This was complicated, however, because in Japan, workers homes were intermingled with factories so that it was impossible to find a target that was exclusively military.
If the atomic bombs had not had the devastating effect they had, they would have been utterly pointless. They now stood poised for the final onslaught. There were domestic considerations as well. The Japanese people know more about that than the American public will ever know.
But just a paragraph later, Leckie reflects writes: Loading Kamikazes were still attacking American vessels.
Pros and cons of dropping the atomic bomb
The United States would have looked weak and foolish. In fact, there is no persuasive evidence that any of them did. For American military commanders, determining the strength of Japanese forces and anticipating the level of civilian resistance were the keys to preparing casualty projections. That the Japanese government was still engaged in good faith diplomatic negotiations with the State Department at the very moment the attack was underway is a singular instance of barbaric behavior that bomb supporters point to as just cause for using the atom bomb. The Japanese stepped up their use of kamikaze attacks, this time sending them at U. In the months preceding the atomic bombings, some 63 million leaflets were dropped on 35 cities target for destruction by U. It is clear from these accounts that while many in the civilian government knew the war could not be won, the power of the military in the Japanese government kept surrender from even being considered as a real option prior to the two atomic bombs. Bomb opponents argue that the atomic bomb was built as a defensive weapon, not an offensive one. According to the official Navy Department Library website, "The day Iwo Jima assault resulted in more than 26, American casualties, including 6, dead" with 19, wounded. Further instructions will be issued concerning targets other than those listed above. They were shunned and ostracized from Japanese society. In a June 27 memo to Stimson, Bard wrote: During recent weeks I have also had the feeling very definitely that the Japanese government may be searching for some opportunity which they could use as a medium of surrender.
They had in their hands a weapon that was capable of bringing the war to a swift end, and so they used it. Those cold statistics and that war-time hatred made using the bomb easy to rationalize.
Now what? He continued: If Russia by some chance should suddenly decide to take advantage of our weakness and intervene against us with force of arms, we would be in a completely hopeless situation. No point in slaughtering civilians for the mere sake of slaughter.
Note: This section is intended as an objective overview of reasons against dropping the atomic bomb.
based on 16 review